Quick answer
- Ask for the breakdown: material, processing, finishing, packaging, tooling, freight — as separate lines.
- Ask which material grade was assumed, and for the mill certificate that proves it.
- Ask whether tooling is amortised into the unit price or billed once, and who owns it afterwards.
- Ask for the price at one, two and five times the quoted quantity.
- Ask whether lead time counts from the purchase order or from the deposit.
- Ask who pays inland haulage, export clearance, freight, insurance and duty.
- Ask what happens if the goods fail inspection — who pays, and how many days to fix it.
1. Is this a price, or a scope?
A single figure usually bundles six things: material, processing, finishing, packaging, tooling and freight. Until they are separate lines, a lower total can simply mean a smaller scope — thinner packaging, no surface treatment, freight excluded. Ask for the breakdown before you compare, and put both quotes into one table with identical rows. Delete every line that is not comparable, then look at what is left.
2. Which material grade was assumed?
“Stainless steel” covers 201, 304 and 316; “ABS” covers virgin and regrind. The grade is where a quote quietly becomes cheaper without anyone lying. Ask for the grade as written on the drawing, the unit weight the factory used, and a mill certificate for the heat they will actually run. If the answer is a grade you did not specify, that is a scope change, not a discount.
3. How was tooling treated?
Tooling is either amortised into the unit price or billed once, and the difference matters most at small volumes. A 6,000 tooling cost spread over 2,000 units adds 3.00 per unit; spread over 20,000 units it adds 0.30. Two quotes can therefore differ by more than the part itself costs, purely because one factory assumed a larger order. Ask which method was used, what volume it assumed, and who owns the tooling if you move the order elsewhere.
4. What is the ladder above and below the quoted quantity?
One price at one quantity tells you very little, because setup and tooling dominate at low volume and material dominates at high volume. Ask for the price at one, two and five times the quoted quantity, and at half of it. If the curve is flat, the quote is probably material-driven and there is little to negotiate. If it drops sharply, you are paying for setup — and the negotiation is about batch size, not about the unit rate.
5. Where does the lead time start?
“Thirty days” means thirty days from something, and that something is usually left unsaid. From purchase order or from deposit cleared? Does it include tooling, material procurement, or only production? Ask for the four dates: deposit received, material in house, first article ready, goods packed. A supplier who can give four dates is managing a schedule; one who gives a single number is repeating a habit.
6. Who pays for what between the factory gate and your warehouse?
EXW, FOB, CIF and DDP move cost and risk between the parties, and the gaps are large enough to reverse a ranking. Ask explicitly who pays inland haulage, export clearance, ocean or air freight, insurance and import duty, and ask for each of those as a number. A quote that looks 6% cheaper at the factory gate can be more expensive landed, and the reverse is just as common.
7. What happens when the goods are wrong?
This is the question that separates a trader from a supplier. Ask for the inspection standard (AQL level and inspection point), who pays return freight for a failed batch, whether rework happens at their cost, and how many days they commit to for a remedy. Also ask how long the price holds and what it is indexed to — metal prices and exchange rates move, and a quote without a validity period is not a commitment.
| What the quote shows |
What to ask |
Why it changes the number |
| One total |
Break it into six lines |
A lower total often hides a smaller scope |
| “Stainless steel” |
Grade, unit weight, mill certificate |
201 versus 304 is a different product |
| Tooling included |
Amortised or billed once, and ownership |
2.70 per unit of difference at 2,000 units |
| One quantity |
Price at 0.5x, 2x and 5x |
Tells you whether setup or material drives it |
| Thirty days |
Four dates, from deposit to packed |
Fifteen days of the total is often procurement |
| FOB price |
Each cost segment as a number |
Landed cost can reverse the ranking |
| No validity stated |
How long it holds, what it is indexed to |
An open-ended price is not a commitment |
Treat a quotation as a document to be normalised, not a number to be negotiated. Once two quotes share the same rows, the negotiation stops being about percentage and starts being about the three lines that actually differ.
None of these questions requires technical knowledge to ask, and most factories answer them without hesitation — which is itself useful information. The ones who cannot produce a breakdown, a grade, or four dates are telling you something about how the order will be run after it is placed.
If you would rather have this done on your behalf, we put quotations from several factories into one comparison sheet with the same rows, flag the lines that differ, and tell you which differences are scope and which are price. That is part of supplier verification, and it usually takes one round of questions.