Typical scenario. Assembled from recurring project patterns, not a single client record. No client name or itinerary is disclosed.
Background
Small kitchen appliance, two candidate factories in the Ningbo area, first order of 8,000 units for the EU. Deliverable: supplier verification before deposit. Timeframe: ten days.
The problem
Both candidates sent the same PDF within a day of each other — same report number, same laboratory, same model family. Only one of them could be telling the truth, and neither had yet been visited.
Scope
Establish which entity the report belongs to, whether the buyer’s variant is covered by it, and what each factory could actually prove about its own production.
What we did
We read the report’s applicant field, not its cover page. The applicant was a third company — the brand owner that had commissioned the original test. One candidate was the OEM that built the product for that brand; the other was a trading company that had received the same PDF from the same brand owner years earlier.
Then we checked the model list against the buyer’s specification. The tested models used a 1.2 m cord and a 1,800 W element; the buyer’s variant was 2,000 W. The report did not cover it.
Both sites were visited anyway, because a report cannot tell you whether the line can hold tolerance at volume.
What we found
The OEM had the tooling, the injection machines and the assembly line, and could explain which components it made and which it bought. The trading company had a showroom, a good English catalogue, and no line. The certificate was real but belonged to a product that was not the product being ordered.
Deliverables
- Verification note per candidate: entity, capability observed on site, documents held.
- Gap list between the tested model and the buyer’s specification.
- Re-test plan with scope, laboratory, lead time and cost.
- Revised order terms: certificate to be issued in the buyer’s model designation before final payment.
Result
The OEM was selected. Re-testing the 2,000 W variant cost about ¥6,000 and three weeks, which was paid once and then reused for every subsequent order. The trading company was kept as a backup quotation source, with the difference stated in writing.
Limitations
- A shared certificate is not automatically fraud; OEM arrangements commonly produce it.
- We test documents and sites, not samples. Performance still has to be verified on the goods.
- Results describe one project; the method transfers, the numbers do not.
Next step
Before you accept a certificate, ask for the applicant name and the model list. Before you pay a deposit, visit. Submit a brief through Submit a Request, or read supplier verification for the document set we check.