Three kinds of sample, three different jobs
- Concept sample — proves the shape is possible. Not a production reference. Do not sign it as one.
- Pre-production sample — made on the actual tool with the actual material. This is the one that matters.
- Golden sample — the signed reference kept by both sides for comparison during production.
Most disputes come from treating a concept sample as a pre-production one, or from having no golden sample at all.
What the sign-off sheet must fix
A usable sheet pins down seven things, and none of them is “good quality”:
- Material grade and supplier, written as a grade code
- Colour reference — a physical standard or a named system, not “as discussed”
- Critical dimensions with tolerance, not nominal only
- Surface finish and where it is allowed to differ
- Assembly fit — what it must mate with, and the acceptable play
- Packaging, including how the sample itself is packed
- Date, version and who signed on each side
What to test versus what to eyeball
Test the things that fail invisibly: wall thickness, pull strength, coating adhesion, colour under a specified light source, and fit against the mating part. Eyeball the things that fail obviously: flash, sink marks, scratches, warpage. A sample that passes the eyeball test and fails the invisible one is the most expensive outcome, because it passes your approval and fails your customer.
Keeping the reference usable
Golden samples degrade. Keep two: one sealed and untouched as the legal reference, one in use for daily comparison. Label both with the same version number as the sign-off sheet, and store them away from sunlight and heat. When a version changes, retire the old one explicitly — two golden samples with no version control is worse than none.
Reject or allow a deviation
A deviation is acceptable when it does not touch a critical dimension, does not change assembly, and is documented before production rather than after. It is not acceptable when it changes the material, the colour standard or anything on the critical list. Write the decision on the sheet either way; an undocumented verbal approval is what turns a small deviation into a full rework.
Next step
If a sample is waiting on your desk and you are not sure what to sign, send the drawing and the supplier’s spec sheet. We will tell you which items are missing from the sheet before you approve.
See how inspection and follow-up work or send the drawing.
Related reading
Where this guide connects
This page is one entry in a category. The service behind it is where the work actually gets done.
Send a request →