Where the cost actually sits
A trading company’s margin is usually 5–15% on the goods, and it appears in one of three places: a higher unit price, a lower specification at the same price, or a fee line you did not ask for. The first is honest, the second is not, and the third depends on whether it was disclosed.
What you get for it is a buffer: one contact instead of five, consolidated shipping, and someone chasing the factory when you are asleep in another time zone.
When a trader is worth it
- Multiple small orders across several factories — consolidation is the product.
- Categories you buy twice a year — the learning cost of a direct relationship never gets amortised.
- Markets where you cannot visit — someone has to stand in the plant.
- Compliance-heavy products — a good trader knows which documents the factory cannot produce alone.
When it is not
Single category, annual volume above roughly 200,000 units, and a factory willing to deal directly. At that point the margin buys you nothing you cannot build yourself, and the information asymmetry starts working against you.
Three questions that separate them
- Which plant makes this, and can I visit it? A trader with a real relationship says yes and comes along.
- Whose name is on the export documents? If the shipper is a third company you have never heard of, that is the factory.
- What happens if I need a second source in the same category? A trader names alternatives; a reseller changes the subject.
The hidden cost that matters most
Not the margin — the information. When a trader controls the factory relationship, you lose visibility on capacity, on quality drift and on price movements. Two years in, you cannot tell whether the price rise is steel or the middle.
What to do about it
If you keep the trader, keep a direct line to the plant: one visit a year, the QC report copied to you, and the factory name on the certificate. If you go direct, budget for the coordination you are taking on — it is real work, not a saving that arrives by itself.
Next step
Tell us the category and volume and we will say whether direct is worth the switch. Submit a request, or read find factories for the screening method.
Related reading