Typical scenario. Assembled from recurring project patterns, not a single client record. No client name or itinerary is disclosed.
Background
Furniture hardware component, five tools in production since 2019. The buyer wanted a second supplier for capacity reasons and asked for the tooling to be moved. Deliverable: tooling ownership audit and handover. Timeframe: three weeks.
The problem
The original purchase order listed a line item reading “tooling fee” with a lump sum and no ownership clause. The supplier’s position was that the fee covered amortisation, not purchase, so the tools stayed with the plant. The buyer’s position was that he had paid for them. Neither side had a document that settled it.
Scope
Establish what could be evidenced per tool, put a cost on each outcome, and produce a handover that both sides would sign. Not in scope: legal action, which we do not provide.
What we did
We built a tool-by-tool inventory: original invoice, payment record, marking on the tool itself, and the correspondence where the tool was first quoted. Then we photographed each tool in the plant and matched the asset tags against the file.
Two tools carried a tag with the buyer’s company name. Two carried no tag at all. One turned out not to be a separate mould but a cavity insert inside a larger tool, which changed the whole negotiation: there was nothing to move.
What we found
Ownership was clean on two, arguable on two, and non-existent on one. The invoice described a total, not an allocation, which is why the dispute was possible in the first place. Rebuilding the two arguable tools was quoted at roughly 40% of the value of the finished goods they produced — cheaper than the delay of a dispute, and it removed the supplier’s leverage.
Deliverables
- Tool inventory with the evidence attached to each line.
- One-page ownership position per tool: clear, arguable, or not a tool.
- Two rebuild quotations on identical specification.
- Handover and tool-transfer agreement covering marking, photos at handover, and who pays transport.
Result
Two tools transferred in three weeks. Two were rebuilt rather than argued over. The cavity insert stayed where it was, because it was never a separate asset. The transfer agreement now goes into every new tooling order as a standard annex.
Limitations
- No legal advice was given; the position memo is a factual record, not a legal opinion.
- The outcome depended on invoices and messages still existing. Where they do not, the answer is usually “rebuild”.
- Results describe one project; the method transfers, the numbers do not.
Next step
If you are about to pay for tooling, the clause matters more than the price. If you are already in the argument, start with the inventory. Submit a brief through Submit a Request, or read the guides on tooling and quotations first.