Quick read · Business guides
Almost every quality dispute in Chinese manufacturing starts in the same place: the sample was made by the sample room, and the order was made by the line. Different people, different machines, different incentives.
What differs
- Who makes it — a technician with twenty years’ experience versus an operator on a target per hour.
- Tooling — prototype tool versus production tool, which is usually built for cycle time.
- Materials — the sample often uses the best available stock, not the lot purchased for the run.
- Time — a sample can take three days; the line has to produce a hundred an hour.
Why it matters commercially
The gap does not appear in the first shipment. It appears in the third, when the sample room has moved on and the line has settled into its real rhythm. By then the buyer has sold the goods.
Three checks before the run
- Line-made sample — ask for a sample produced on the production tool, by a line operator, and inspect that one.
- First article — the first piece off the run, measured against the drawing, signed by QC and by you.
- Retained reference — one unit from the first article sealed and kept by both sides, dated.
What to write into the order
Name the reference: “quality standard per the sealed first article dated X, retained by both parties”. Anything vaguer — “as per sample”, “good quality” — is not a standard, it is a starting position for a negotiation you will lose.
If the supplier refuses a line-made sample
That refusal is information. Either the tool is not ready, or the line cannot hold the tolerance. Both are worth knowing before the deposit rather than after the container.
Next step
Send the product and we will tell you which of the three checks is missing from your current process. Submit a request, or read sample approval.
What to photograph at the first article
Four photographs, taken the same day and kept with the measurement sheet: the part next to a ruler or caliper reading, the assembly joint, the surface finish under raking light, and the packaging as it left the line. Six months later these four are what a dispute is argued with, not the sample room’s studio photo.
Label them with the date, the lot and the machine number. A photograph without a lot number documents that something existed, not that this shipment matched it.
Related reading